The fda has approved several bard hernia mesh devices for use in hernia repair surgical procedures through the fda 510k process. Another barddavol hernia mesh product is ventralex, approved in 2002. The food and drug administration fda has estimated that up to 90% of the nearone million hernia repair surgeries may use surgical mesh to stabilize abdominal or groin tissue. One patient died in march 2007 after developing a fistula and infection following her hernia surgery, and another died after an emergency bowel surgery compromised the patch. Kugel hernia patch modified kugel hernia patch sepramesh ip seprmatex visilex 3d light mesh allomax surgical graft bard mesh bard mesh preshaped. Davol acquired the kugel hernia patch from surgical sense inc. Eventually, the ck patch was designed with two layers of polypropylene mesh, a layer of eptfe, and a pet memory recoil ring welded between the layers of polypropylene mesh.
If an infection develops, treat the infection aggressively. The use of any synthetic mesh or patch in a contaminated or infected wound can lead to fistula formation andor extrusion of the mesh and is not recommended. Class i recalls were issued for composix kugel patch, manufactured by c. The kugel mesh is a circular patch featuring an innovative springloaded ring. Contains a permanent internal polyethylene terephthalate pet ring to help maintain its shape. The ventrio hernia patchs unique design and technique offer patients the benefits of an. Since october 2005, there have been several davol bard composix kugel hernia mesh recall for certain patches containing a design defects which may result in serious and potentially fatal injuries. Once again, bard medical the company that brought defective products to the. Recall classified as class i because the defect associated with the use or exposure to the bard composix kugel mesh large patch has a reasonable probability to cause serious. Patch, kugel hernia patch, ck parastomal patch and modified kugel patch. Bard assured the fda and the public that the problem was limited to a few defective rings inside of a limited number of kugel hernia patches. Kugel patch hernia mesh complications and legal claims. Bard davol hernia mesh mess hernia mesh lawsuit update. Bards modified kugel device the hernia mesh product that replaced the bard kugel patch came equipped.
Bard hernia mesh lawsuit dangerous side effects reported. Bard composix kugel hernia patch large oval with eptfe, 5. Hernia mesh lawsuit surgical injuries and complications. The kugel hernia patch davol, cranston, ri, usa for treatment of inguinal hernias is a minimal access technique of inguinal herniorrhaphy, which aims to combine the utility of the open operation with the advantages of the laparoscopic procedures. Bard modified kugel selfexpanding mesh patch w strap for anterior approach to preperitoneal hernia repair. By pushing the hernia back through the abdominal wall and then inserting the patch on the hernia location through an incision in a patients groin, a surgeon could induce scar tissue that, together with the mesh, supported and strengthened the muscles there.
The 510k process does not require a manufacturer to prove that a product is safe for its intended use, but merely requires a showing that a device is a substantive equivalent to a product or products already approved by the fda. It had a defective ring that could break and puncture organs. The real defect of the kugel hernia patch is that the ring is inside of a polypropylene mesh. The ring allows the product to spring open once implanted, adding structural support and stability. Bard hernia mesh may have caused serious injuries in patients who received the implant during a hernia repair procedure. There have been issues with the kugel hernia patch since its inception. The kugel mesh was intended for the repair of two types of hernia. Despite thousands of serious adverse event reports, only a few hernia mesh products have been removed from the market. The hernia mesh used can be synthetic commonly a bunch of plasticbased threads that look like fine fishing string and are woven into a mesh or actual tissue from humans, pigs or cows. Over a million kugel patches have been implanted nationwide.
By 2018, bard had stopped marketing the kugel hernia patch in the u. The kugel hernia patch is one of bards earliest and most problematic mesh products. Bard hernia mesh lawsuit attorneys boston defective. However, rings continue to break and patients continue to get injured. The patch is then held open by its memory recoil ring, a thin ring that allows the patch to be. Inguinal hernia repair with the kugel patch reddy 2005. Preperitoneal groin hernia repair with a bard modified kugel patch. The bard modified kugel patch was a circular shaped hernia mesh implant with a metal ring inside of it. Composix ex, kugel hernia patch and lp kugel hernia patch and modified marlex. The bard kugel patch was an implantable medical device that used to be used to treat inguinal hernias. If you or a loved one is a victim of a defective bard kugel hernia product, fill out the form below for a free legal consultation. The sale of this item may be subject to regulation by the u. In december 2005, the fda warned that hernia mesh patches containing a memory recoil ring could break and cause injury.
While the mk patch was designed to update bards problematic kugel hernia patch, the modified kugel patch was plagued with many of the same problems of its predecessor. Bard due to threat of severe injury that could be caused by the plastic used in the mesh which could splinter and migrate away from the. Bard reported it settled some lawsuits related to use of the composix kugel mesh patch. Greyturners sign after modified kugel herniorrhaphy 5929 int j clin exp med 2014. On b6 2008 the bard modified kugel patch was removed. Many patients and physicians have reported the internal ring of the kugel breaking and perforating the bowel or other organs. Bard medical is at it again with defective hernia patches drug. Bard first recalled the patch in 2005 after the company said it could cause bowel perforations and fistulas.
The hernia mesh patch at the center of this latest round of litigation against the new jerseybased company was designed, manufactured and marketed by davol, a bard subsidiary since 1980. The composix kugel mesh patch is surgically implanted via a small incision, positioned behind the hernia, and its memory coil ring opens the patch behind the herniated area. The bard kugel patch davol, cranston, rhode island was developed to facilitate performance of the kugel hernia repair. The bard kugel patch was meant to treat these hernias. We are a liquidator of sutures and other surgical items from ethicon, covidien autosuture, synthes, stryker, arthrex and are able to pass our savings on to you. Bard, but was phased out during the 2000s with the introduction of the bard modified kugel patch, which was also known as the mk patch. A 2006 class i recalls was issued due to threat of severe injury that could be caused by the composix kugel patch, manufactured by c. Patients with the bard kugel hernia patch who have experienced infection, mesh erosion, severe pain, and revision surgery may be eligible for financial compensation for injuries.
The fda issued the following kugel mesh hernia patch safety alert on 2107. The bard ventralex hernia patch is intended for use in all forms of hernia repair requiring reinforcement with a non absorbable support material. Bard is one of the largest manufacturers of hernia mesh products, some of. Greyturners sign after modified kugel herniorrhaphy. Bard was subject to recalls for composix kugel mesh products due to safety concerns about the plastic which would splinter and migrate away from the surgical site. Bard medical is at it again with defective hernia patches. The problems led to several recalls and thousands of lawsuits. Bard in 2006 but the majority of bards products remain on the market. The latest product in this grim parade is the kugel hernia patch, which.
Bard davol hernia mesh timeline will there be a bard hernia mesh settlement. Unresolved infection may require removal of the mesh. Hernia mesh cases set for trial nationwide mass tort nexus. After the 3 days of operation, grey turners sign was discovered at the left waist, and then 10 days later, the sign disappeared. The pet ring was the subject of an fda class i recall in 2005, 2006, and 2007. The operation was well done and there was no obviously bleeding. The plastic mesh that made up the older bard kugel patch was known to erode after implantation in a patient. The patch is used to repair ventral, inguinal, and laparoscopic hernias.
Class 1 device recall davol composix kugel hernia patch. After insertion through a small incision, the patch is placed behind the hernia defect. Bard davol designed its kugel patch for minimallyinvasive hernia mesh surgery. Bard modified kugel patch,the modified kugel patch repair is a minimally invasive, tensionfree technique that can be completed through a small 46 cm incision and requires minimal suturing. Although it is started out as a simple singlelayer mesh, it became progressively more intricate in order to make the performance of the. A great variety of hernia mesh products have been manufactured by bard including but not limited to. Consideration should be given regarding the need to remove the mesh. Bard and its subsidiary davol recalled limited lots of the kugel hernia patch in 2005.
It is a preperitoneal repair performed through an open, anterior approach that can be completed using local or regional anesthesia. Patient had a bard modified kugel patch implanted during this procedure. A class i recall was issued by the fda for the composix kugel patch manufactured by c. While the litigation focused on the composix kugel hernia patch, some cases involved other bard hernia products such as the composix ex mesh, ventralex hernia patch, composix hernia patch, kugel hernia patch, ck parastomal patch and modified kugel patch. The aim of the present study is to report an initial experience of a cohort of patients with inguinal hernias undergoing repair using. Bard davol recalled its kugel patch hernia mesh in 2005. Ventralex is a hernia mesh patch made of polyproplene. The hernia mesh is basically a small piece of netting, mostly in a sheet or a plug, which is used to provide additional support to a weakened or damaged area. This can lead to bowel perforations rupture andor chronic recurring intestinal fistulae abnormal connections or passageways between the intestines and other organs. Bard hernia mesh linked to injuries drug and device watch.
Bard kugel, 3dmax, ventralex, sepramesh kugel mesh hernia patch. Bard then quickly came out with the modified kugel, which incorporated polypropylene straps that could be pulled to make it easier to manipulate the kugel to lay flat against the abdominal wall. The fda sent a recall letter regarding the composix kugel mesh patch in march 2006 to physicians and patients advising patients implanted with a recalled device to seek immediate medical attention. Bard also attempted to fix the kugels devastating ring break problem. Expanded medial and inferior coverage for direct and femoral hernia spaces. Download free software modified kugel patch adventuresfiles.
Endless claims against kugel mesh hernia patch youtube. Two layers of small pore, heavyweight polypropylene attached to a single layer of eptfe. The bard mk patch, also known as the modified kugel patch, is an implantable medical device used in inguinal hernia procedures. Chief among them was a tendency for the plastic mesh to erode and shrink. The kugel patch is manufactured by davol, inc, which is a division of c. With more than 50 years of clinical experience, bard mesh is the gold standard product to be used in a tensionfree hernia repair technique. Kugel hernia patch modified kugel hernia patch sepramesh ip seprmatex visilex 3d light mesh. Bard composix kugel patch and products in its transvaginal mesh line were constructed of marlex plastic. The modified kugel patch also had mesh straps that could be used to more easily reposition and manipulate the patch, once it had been implanted. So far, this has been the largest settlement amount in any hernia mesh litigation.
140 935 1310 725 672 1511 1222 314 1516 1093 1000 1339 241 125 614 175 490 106 59 299 1501 588 528 259 290 62 743 465 173 382 19 359 585 1455 1231 958 1277